Skip to content
apple-investor

Apple Investor

Investing News and Strategies

Primary Menu
  • Analysts
  • Apple Products
  • News
  • Trading
  • Home
  • 2013
  • April
  • How To Rate Apple Analysts
  • Analysts

How To Rate Apple Analysts

Frances Henderson April 7, 2013 3 min read
how-to-rate-apple-analysts-2

There are few people on the planet that can destroy wealth faster than an Apple analyst. With the release of a single ill-timed investor note, Apple stock can plummet 2-3 percent, wiping out $billions of shareholder value, not to mention the affect on futures and dozens of derivative stocks. By what right has such immense power been bestowed upon these people. If they had real talent, they’d be clawing for a spot on the brokerage sales desk, because that’s where the real money is.

The fact is most analysts have very little investing or trading experience, and they do very little of the actual data collection and analysis. They are nothing more than glorified financial reporters. Of course this is my opinion, and I’m sure there’s now a big fat bull’s eye on my extensive forehead.

So, let’s look at the facts. For this I’ll turn to Philip Elmer-Dewitt of the Apple 2.0 blog, who has been compiling data on all the top professional and amateur Apple analysts over the past four years, which ranks them based on accuracy over specified periods. And the interesting thing is the data is all over the place. An exhaustive study would likely show that any analyst has an equal shot in any period of outranking the next.

At any time, an analyst might release a investor note that could affect Apple’s price and in turn, your position…something you never figured into your analysis. So, consider that brokerages employ these spokespersons, who play reckless with our fortunes.

Let’s consider the methods analysts use to compute the value of Apple. But before I get into their flawed methods, let me preface with the fact that most analysts covering Apple, don’t even use Apple products.

Ask yourself, how many times have you tried to make sense of an analyst’s statement, where they’ve demonstrated a complete misunderstanding of Apple culture, the ecosystem, or the fan base. This isn’t universal of course, some analysts are very knowledgeable and huge Apple fans, but even a respected Apple bull like Gene Munster ranks only in the middle of the pack, well behind several amateur analysts. Some of the most influential analysts rank near the bottom of the pack, like Charlie Wolf and Kathy Huberty.

And when I say, “most influential,” what I mean is they have the greatest ability to affect Apple stock price due to their affiliation with a prominent brokerage, or they have strong media coverage. And this strong coverage isn’t based on meritocracy, it’s usually based on some past blunder or outrageous statement they made, or under rare circumstances some lucky call.

So, why do we place so much weight on an Apple analyst’s opinion, when they are more likely than not to be wrong, and therefore will misguide you in your investing and trading decisions? It’s a rhetorical question.

I won’t waste your time with an exhaustive study of the methods used to value Apple, you can click here for that. Instead I’ll just point out a few more reasons why fundamental analysis techniques have little or no validity. So, besides the fact that most analysts use freshers right out of school to collect and analyze the data, most of the data collected is out of date. Things move fast in this industry, and six month to year old data doesn’t cut it.

A related problem is their conclusions are dated, usually good for only a few months time. How often have you seen analysts restate their target price after a minor, or perceived miss (whisper miss) on an earnings report, or a spy report on supply chain data?

If fundamental analysis had any validity at all, if it was a tried and true scientific method, being performed by experienced and wise analysts, then you would think they would agree for the most part, or at least be in the same ballpark. But you can forget that, because 40 different analysts looking at the exact same data will come up with 40 different conclusions.

The title of this article is, How To Rate An Apple Analyst. Well, the answer is, don’t even try, they’re likely to be wrong. The best advice is to use your own research, formulate your own thesis, and develop your own conclusions. Then, when you lose money, you can put the blame where it belonged in the first place.

Continue Reading

Previous: Top AAPL Analyst Muddies Black Friday Results
Next: Apple Analyst Watch – Keeping Tabs On Every Move

Related Stories

Who Do You Believe About Apple Growth, Analyst Hacks Or A Self-Made Billionaire? who-do-you-believe-about-apple-growth-analyst-hacks-or-a-self-made-billionaire-2
2 min read
  • Analysts

Who Do You Believe About Apple Growth, Analyst Hacks Or A Self-Made Billionaire?

July 10, 2015
Apple Analysts Don’t Have A Clue – They Just Follow | AppleInvestor apple-analysts-dont-have-a-clue-they-just-follow-appleinvestor
2 min read
  • Analysts

Apple Analysts Don’t Have A Clue – They Just Follow | AppleInvestor

April 13, 2015
Andy Hargreaves – Head Butts Fellow Analysts And Says New iPhones Will Rock andy-hargreaves-head-butts-fellow-analysts-and-says-new-iphones-will-rock-2
1 min read
  • Analysts
  • Apple Products

Andy Hargreaves – Head Butts Fellow Analysts And Says New iPhones Will Rock

May 2, 2014

Recent Posts

  • Alligator Indicator by Bill Williams
  • Best Stocks To Invest In
  • Blue Chip Stocks
  • How do I go about Investing My Money?
  • How to Evaluate Your Investments in 6 Easy Steps

News

Only 38 Days to Apple’s WWDC15 only-38-days-to-apples-wwdc15-2
2 min read
  • News

Only 38 Days to Apple’s WWDC15

Frances Henderson June 11, 2016
Apple’s World Wide Developer Conference starts on Monday June 8th and ends on the following Friday, June...
Read More
Apple Confirms October 16 It’s Been Way Too Long Event apple-confirms-october-16-its-been-way-too-long-event-2
1 min read
  • News

Apple Confirms October 16 It’s Been Way Too Long Event

Frances Henderson June 11, 2016
Apple confirmed yesterday that it would be hosting an event on Thursday October 16th. Sure, that much...
Read More
Apple Takes the Lead in Supplier Responsibility, Accountability apple-takes-the-lead-in-supplier-responsibility-accountability-2
5 min read
  • News

Apple Takes the Lead in Supplier Responsibility, Accountability

Frances Henderson June 11, 2016
It’s old news, yet Apple haters still argue with me, that Apple runs sweatshops in China, where...
Read More
Apple Volatility is on the Plate for 2015 apple-volatility-is-on-the-plate-for-2015-2
3 min read
  • News

Apple Volatility is on the Plate for 2015

Frances Henderson June 11, 2016
Happy New Year, and What a great year 2014 was for the Apple Auto Trader! This past...
Read More
How Did Apple’s Post Earnings Crash Affect You? how-did-apples-post-earnings-crash-affect-you-2
3 min read
  • News

How Did Apple’s Post Earnings Crash Affect You?

Frances Henderson June 11, 2016
[vc_row][vc_column width=”1/1″][vc_column_text]Be honest, I won’t tell. Did your brokerage account suffer a serious ding from that surprise...
Read More

You may have missed

Alligator Indicator by Bill Williams Alligator Indicator
7 min read
  • Apple Products
  • Trading

Alligator Indicator by Bill Williams

August 2, 2021
Best Stocks To Invest In stocks
4 min read
  • Investing
  • Trading

Best Stocks To Invest In

July 26, 2021
Blue Chip Stocks blue-chip-stocks
4 min read
  • Investing
  • Trading

Blue Chip Stocks

July 20, 2021
How do I go about Investing My Money? moneymoney
4 min read
  • Investing
  • Trading

How do I go about Investing My Money?

July 12, 2021
  • Terms of Use
  • Disclaimer
  • Strategy
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Testimonials
  • What You Get
Copyright © Apple-Investor. All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.